top of page

Open MRI vs. Closed MRI: Which One Should You Choose?

Feb 13, 2025
5 min read

Updated: Oct 29

Choosing between an open MRI and a closed MRI comes down to two things: what your doctor needs to see, and what you can comfortably handle. Closed MRIs often give more detailed images. Open MRIs feel less confining. The best choice is the one that gets clear pictures of the right area while keeping you calm enough to lie still.


MRI scanner used to compare open MRI vs closed MRI options

This guide walks you through the questions to think about, from claustrophobia and body size to pain and scan length, so you can have a helpful talk with your doctor.


The basic difference


A closed MRI is a tube-shaped scanner. You lie on a table that slides into the opening, and the magnet surrounds your body.


An open MRI usually has the magnet above and below you, with open sides. You are not inside a tube, so it can feel more spacious.


There is also a middle option at some centers called a wide-bore MRI. It is still a closed, tube-shaped scanner, but with a larger opening than older models.


How well each type shows detail is a topic on its own. If image quality is your main question, read our guide: are open MRIs as accurate as traditional MRIs? This article focuses on choosing based on your comfort and needs.


Start with your doctor's goal


Your doctor orders an MRI to answer a specific question. That question matters most. Some exams need very fine detail, and your doctor may want a stronger closed scanner. Other exams may work well on more than one type of machine.


Before you decide, ask your doctor:


  • What body part is being scanned, and what are you looking for?

  • Does this exam need a high-detail scanner?

  • Would an open MRI give you the information you need?

  • If the first scan isn't clear, would I need to repeat it?


Questions to ask yourself


Once you know what the exam needs, think about your own comfort. These questions can help.


Do tight spaces make me anxious?


If you have strong claustrophobia, an open MRI may feel easier. But many people with mild to moderate anxiety do fine in a closed scanner with some preparation. Being honest with your doctor about how you feel helps them plan.


Can I lie still for the whole scan?


Staying still is one of the most important parts of getting clear pictures. Open MRIs often take longer, which means more time holding still. If you have pain that makes lying still hard, a shorter scan may actually be easier for you. Learn more about what happens if you move during an MRI.


Will I fit comfortably?


Scanners have size and weight limits. Some larger patients find an open or wide-bore scanner more comfortable. If you are unsure, call the imaging center ahead of time and ask. This can save you a trip.


Do I have trouble getting into position?


If you have limited movement, back pain, or a recent injury, ask how you will be positioned. The technologist can often use pads and cushions to help you stay comfortable.


Do I want someone nearby?


Some people feel calmer with a family member close by. Ask whether a companion can stay in the room. Anyone who goes in must complete the same metal safety screening you do.


Side-by-side: what to weigh


Your need

Closed MRI

Open MRI

Fine image detail

Often the better fit

May be less detailed for some exams

Strong claustrophobia

Can feel tight

Usually feels easier

Shorter time on the table

Often shorter

Often longer

Larger body size

Depends on scanner opening

Often more room

Staying still with pain

Shorter scans can help

Longer scans can be harder


Tips to make a closed MRI easier


If your doctor recommends a closed MRI and you feel nervous, these simple steps help many people:


  • Ask the technologist to walk you through what will happen

  • Close your eyes before the table slides in

  • Breathe slowly in through your nose and out through your mouth

  • Ask for music or headphones to help with the noise

  • Remember you can talk with the technologist during the scan

  • Talk with your doctor ahead of time if your anxiety is severe


MRIs are loud, so it helps to know what to expect. Our article on why MRIs are so loud explains the sounds. For more calming ideas, see how to overcome claustrophobia during an MRI.


What stays the same with either type


No matter which scanner you use, a few things don't change:


  • MRI does not use radiation

  • You will complete a metal safety screening before the scan

  • You will need to remove jewelry, watches, and other metal items

  • You'll need to stay as still as you can during each part of the scan

  • A radiologist reads the images and sends a report to your doctor


Frequently asked questions


Is an open MRI better for claustrophobia?


For many people, yes. The open sides can feel much less confining. Some people with claustrophobia also do well in a closed scanner with breathing tips, music, and a clear explanation of each step.


Which is faster, open or closed MRI?


Closed MRIs are often faster because many use stronger magnets. Open MRIs may need more time to collect clear images. The exact time depends on the machine and the body part.


Can I choose which type of MRI I get?


You can ask. Your doctor will weigh your comfort against what the exam needs to show. Imaging centers can also tell you what type of scanner they use.


What is a wide-bore MRI?


A wide-bore MRI is a closed, tube-shaped scanner with a larger opening than older models. It can feel roomier while working like a traditional closed scanner.


What should I tell the imaging center before my scan?


Let them know about claustrophobia, pain, trouble lying flat, your body size if you have concerns, and any implants or devices in your body. This helps the team prepare.


Related reading



Schedule an MRI at Millenium MRI


Millenium MRI has centers in Ocala, Largo, and Tamarac, Florida, and in North Little Rock, Springdale, Jonesboro, and Marion, Arkansas. Our ARRT-certified technologists will walk you through each step, and most patients are in and out in about 35 minutes. Same-day appointments are often available, and we accept most insurance plans, workers' compensation, personal injury cases, and self-pay. If you have questions about our scanners or your comfort, call your nearest center before your visit.



This article is for general information and is not medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your specific situation.


Comments


bottom of page